Single-payer healthcare is the right system. Can California build it on its own?


MICHAEL HILTZIK |BUSINESS COLUMNIST

JAN. 14, 2022 6 AM PT


California, which has shown the determination to go it alone in areas such as environmental protection, scientific research and workers’ rights when its values conflict with policies at the federal level, is moving forward with its most audacious effort yet.


That’s a plan to create a universal single-payer healthcare system.


Called CalCare, the program would take over health coverage for more than 40 million residents from government policies such as Medicare and Medicaid and from private plans whether sponsored by employers or purchased through the Affordable Care Act marketplace.


“We can’t have that cost containment ability without having the massive bargaining power of every single Californian.”

CARMEN COMSTI, CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSN.


This would mean placing $400 billion in annual expenditures in the hands of a state governing board. Say goodbye to the dead hand of private health insurers, to navigating in-network and out-of-network charges, to deductibles and co-pays, to substandard dental, vision and hearing services. Every resident of the state, regardless of where they get their their coverage now, would be eligible for the new system.


At least, that’s the promise. Whether the Legislature will be able to bring this idea to fruition is anyone’s guess.


Under its rules, the measure embodying the program, AB 1400, must be sent by Jan. 31 from the Assembly to the Senate, where it is likely to be masticated into the summer. The proposal, like its several predecessors introduced in recent years, is sponsored by the California Nurses Assn.


Not a few Assembly members have already expressed skepticism, but it’s a bit early to pull the plug. I agree with my colleague George Skelton that this is “a debate worth having.”


But it’s not a debate coming out of the blue. Indeed, it is sure to have a heavy component of déja vu. California has tried to enact a universal single-payer program many times in the past. Each time, it foundered over concerns about its cost and opposition from politically potent interests such as the commercial insurance industry and the California Medical Assn.


In 2018, for instance, a proposal almost identical to AB 1400 was torpedoed by Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon (D-Lakewood). The uproar his action generated, however, forced him to establish a legislative committee to examine how achieve universal health coverage in the state.

READ MORE

BACK TO

MISSION

HC4US advocates for comprehensive, high-quality universal health care through single-payer public financing. Our goal is to guarantee health care as a human right for ALL California residents, advancing the larger fight for health care justice and energizing the implementation of national Single Payer/Medicare for All.

CONTACT

HC4US

Health Care for  US

info@hc4us.org

Phone: (310)459-9763

DONATE

Your contribution helps our ongoing work to guarantee comprehensive, high-quality health care as a human right and lead in the larger fight for health care justice. 

To chip in, go here.